If you want something other than pizza, go somewhere else!!. I have tried the food twice. The pizza is good. I just this last time had the shrimp basket. There are HUGE black veins left in the shrimp that run the length of them, it's gross. The potato skins appetizer is bare and cheese is hard. For pizza, I guess so, but the other sandwiches and baskets.. yuck.
Marty's offers a lot of great side items and appetizers, but they are really known for their pizzas!
Good pizza, bizarre atmosphere.
Let me start off by saying I do like Marty's pizza. It's got a unique taste unlike the other pizzerias in the area. If you're just doing carryout, I'd likely recommend them.
The last couple of times our family dined in, it was nearly impossible to have a conversation because of the extremely loud christian rock music playing over the sound system. I expect a certain amount of background music when we go out to eat but it was by far louder than what was reasonable and because it was on repeated occasions not just a random occurance, I confess I have yet to go back nor do I have any desire to.
Over rated!. Marty's is a generic family pizzeria. Picture minivans full of rugrats arriving in the parking lot and you've got an accurate impression of this place. (it's got an arcade room to occupy the little monsters) The pizza is ok, but very far from the best in Milwaukee. It's actually bland and inoffensive, to appeal to the unsophisticated tastes of all the youngsters, I imagine. Definitely not the best in town...
Great thin crust pizza. Marty's is a geat place to take a family for excellent thin crust pizza. Service is normally very good, and it's a relaxed, casual atmosphere where kids fit in well. The pizza's are big and are always good.
Spectacular Italian Cuisine. Not only does Marty's have some of the best thin-crust pizza in town, but they also offer many other options in Italian dining. The food, all around, is delicious, no matter what you order, and the toppings you want are always there. I recommend putting pineapple on your pizza there. It gives the pizza a new, flavorful taste!
THE BEST DAMN PIZZA!. Martys is the best damn pizza i have ever eaten,how could anyone disagree,i'll tell you,when they have never tried it before! I rate Martys a 10,for being perfect,good veggies,good sauce,good cheese,good meat,REALLY good garlic bread,just all around the best damn pizza!
None better. Excellent - different toppings are all great. All experiences have been takeout and all have been consistently great.
Tulls. The best pizza I've had so far in Milwaukee area
Best Pizza I have ever had!. Marty's pizza is the best pizza I have ever had. Everything is made with fresh ingredients, and the pizza is never greesy! I also recomend their garlic bread, it is the best around made with Marty's home made bread.
Skipping on our Homemade garlic bread isn't even an option....and our pizza will never be greasy because we use 100% whole mozz cheese made right here in THE BEST CHEESE STATE (Wisconsin)!
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!