Quaint Irish pub offers a friendly respite on bustling Water Street.. In Short Housed in a historic turn-of-the-century building, Fitzgibbon's is the kind of homey place where it seems like everybody really does know your name. The decor is classic tavern, with a handsome antique bar and bar stools with Irish-green leather seats. Old-time photos of Milwaukee line the walls. The outdoor bar is popular and can get quite crowded during the summer.