Authentic Caribbean... Serious?.
This is NOT authentic Jamaican fare. Okay "Coconut chicken strips"... The dish does suggest that you're getting an "americanized" version of something authentic, but when you list "Jerk Chicken" or "Jerk Pork" on your menu... Authentic jerk chicken is slow cooked in a 55 gal drum over wood coals. The bones are left in the meat and cooked with the meat. The same goes for jerk pork. The "Jerk" is sauce, and is served on the side. That is what I was expecting... Being "Authentic" and all. Instead, I got diced, cooked chicken floating in Walkers Woods sauce. The jerk pork was terrible. It had the same consistancy of pate'. I have no idea how either of these were cooked. My best guess is boiled. My wife had a salad which was huge.
Good bet for the money, and hard to screw up. She also had the Coconut Shrimp, which she enjoyed greatly. She is the only reason I gave 2 stars... She insisted. Don't be fooled when you read their description of their restaraunt. It's not authentic!
Ohhh, and they don't have Ting either!
Seemed like an okay place. Seems like a decent enough place. Went there Friday night, we didn't get there until 8:30 and was told by the hostess there would be an hour and 15 minute wait. Looking around it didn't seem like it would take that long and it didn't. It took about 10 minutes. Waiter was good. We had the 1/2 order of nachos to snack on for the 4 of us (two couples) and there was plenty left over. My wife wasn't thrilled with her veggie wrap for dinner. Veggie wrap? Really?? Anyhow, the rest of us had the fish fry. Potato pancake was okay, but better than a lot of places. Fish was nothing special, but wasn't bad. I was just happy it was all you can eat.
Turned Off. I just heard about the most unprofessional approach from management and the discrimination that my friends have experienced. I've always knew about the infamous tuesdays and thursdays. But...to be accused of not "tipping" first of all that is a choice....it means to insure prompt service. The customer is always right. These women were treated as though they were teenagers bailing out on a bill. Once this circulates its going to be bad business...word of mouth goes a long way. It's really sad that people still treat people this way. Milwaukee is still segregated and its a shame. Before you decide to pick a new place like Jamaican...just know this is not authentic nor is it catered friendly!
One of My Favorites.
We have been going to the Painted Parrot since they first opened in their old location. When they moved, we followed.... we love the new location and their food.
Their fish fry is one of the best I have ever eaten. The breading is light and very flavorful, but not overpowering as to take away from the fish. It is all you can eat and I think it is so cute that they serve it in a garbage can cover.
I also have enjoyed their crab legs on numerous occasions. They are very meaty and can be eaten without butter!
My newest favorite is the jerked burger and although they say it is spicy, I find it to be mild, but delicious. My husband raves about the steak sandwich and usually orders it every time we go.
I love their fries, but always order the smashed potatoes. Their nachos are huge (could easily be a meal for a crowd) and the cheese, etc. are layed throughout the chips not just thrown on top.
In all my visits I have never encountered food that wasn't fresh and flavorful. I would highly recommend a visit some time soon.
It's a Keeper!. My husband and I truly enjoyed our first meal at the Painted Parrot this evening. Even though it was busy (a Saturday night), we only waited 10 minutes for a table. The waitstaff was very professional, friendly, and genuinely polite. We had the curried pork and the jambalaya. The food was very spicy and flavorful. The atmosphere was fun and lively. We'll definitely go back to try some of their other dishes.
No Place Like It In Milwaukee. The 3 negative reviews are from the same person. The individual was terminated last year. We invite you to try the Painted Parrot. It truly is the areas ONLY caribbean restaurant.
Avoid all together. My husband and I were not impressed with this restaurant. The waitresses were lazy, and seemed like they didnt know how to seat people, the food was nothing to rave about. The lettuce they serve under the meat was brown and wilted. The meat servings were small. I ordered a mojito and when it came to the table the limes were brown and just looked spoiled. I have been to Jamaica 3 times and this food is far away from it. The menu says the food is spicy but it wasn't at all. We will probably never go back!!!!
No Crab Except For the Owner. My friend was leaving the country and got all her friends together for her Going Away. She heard they had All You Can Eat Crab at Painted Parrot. She called for reservations for 14 of us. They told her there was another party of 24 so they couldn't guarantee crab for her whole party. She said that only a few of us would be eating it. They said it would be okay and made the reservation. When we got seated the party of 24 was already seated and eating their crab and being served their other meals. When we ordered 3 people in our party wanted crab. We were told they didn't have enough to even serve 1 person due to the other party. Quite the disappointment, but they were apologetic. Then we waited well over an hour for our food. I went to complain. The host said she would talk to the owner. She said the party of 24 placed their food order at the same time as us and that is why it was taking so long. I told her the other party was served before we even ordered. She then said that they pre-placed their order that is why. I tell her this is unacceptable service and we should be compensated. She again mentions getting the owner. She disappears and doesn't return. After our server brings our bill, I tell him we never got to talk to the owner. He comes out on immediate defense. He tries to tell me that they told my friend on the phone of this other party and that if we came it would be over an hour wait and they did all they could to detour her from coming. She tells him this isn't so. He then orders me to follow him to his kitchen. He showed me how small his kitchen was and continued to give more excuses. He argued with me with his whole staff watching. He refused to compensate for the lousy service. It was the most ridiculous and unprofessional experience I have ever been witness too. We arrived at 6 and didn?t get out of there till 9.
Avoid the crab legs. I thought this place was terrible for the all you can eat crab legs, they only bring out 2-3 legs at a time and they are so wet they just drip down your arm and water all over the table. Now if you can't eat a lot of crab this place would be ok, buy myself I know how to eat crab and hated to have to keep waiting to find the waiter to get 3 more legs, I told him I am good at eating these couldn't I have more than 3 at a time, he said no that's their rules. You can go right down the street to Paulies, and get their all you can eat crabs on Wednesday and Saturday, much better place. And Paulies all you can eat means your sides too.
Classic Caribbean fare on the West Side, right across from State Fair Park..
This festive island joint serves up authentic Caribbean-inspired dishes like jerk pork, coconut chicken strips, Cajun burgers and Creole-style gumbo. Signature cocktails are so fruity and refreshing that you almost feel warm tropical breezes blowing. The service is friendly and the ambience makes use of bright colors. And yes, there really is a parrot inside--it's a gigantic tropics-themed mural painted by Milwaukee artist Steve Draeger.
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!