save Eddie Martini's

8612 W Watertown Plank Rd, Milwaukee, WI | Map it  

53226 43.046200 -88.019801

(414) 771-6680 | View Website

Sign in to Write a Review

My Rating

Reviews from Citysearch

Sort by:

AngelAtPiano

Member since Dec, 2010 View Profile
2Reviews
0Photos
Joined 2 years ago
5.0
December 03, 2010

One of my favorite restaurants!. If you have a special occasion, this is the place to have it at! I have been here a few times before and wish I could afford to go here more often :) You are missing out if you have never been here before.

View More View Less
0

trgottschall

Member since Jul, 2002 View Profile
15Reviews
0Photos
Joined 10 years ago
5.0
May 06, 2010

Best in all of Milwaukee. This is fine dining at its best. Excellent seafood. Amazing wine list. I've been here 4 times in the last year. Don't miss out on this restaurant when in Milwaukee.

0

BoxerPuncher

Member since Dec, 2008 View Profile
9Reviews
0Photos
Joined 4 years ago
5.0
November 29, 2009

Perfect steak. Mr B's is mine and my wife's favorite, and EM's is right there with them.

0

djaffurs

Member since Jun, 2008 View Profile
1Review
0Photos
Joined 4 years ago
4.0
June 23, 2008

Food:Price ratio. The food is not as good as the hype (or the price!), but the atmosphere and service are excellent.

0

leemilwaukee

Member since May, 2008 View Profile
2Reviews
0Photos
Joined 4 years ago
5.0
May 30, 2008

Great Steaks and Chops. Eddie Martinis is one of the hallmark restaurants in the Milwaukee area. The atmosphere is cozy and the food is great. When the lamb chops are on the menu - be sure to get them as they are excellent. Also a good place to meet after work for a drink. Their martini menu is very good.

View More View Less
0

reddyn

Member since Oct, 2006 View Profile
8Reviews
0Photos
Joined 6 years ago
4.0
October 27, 2006

Average!. Ive lived in Milwaukee for over 10 years and usually try every new restaurant close to its opening. However, I only visited Eddie Martini's a couple months ago. The place was hyped quite a bit in my mind. However, I was slightly disappointed with my steak. It wasn't bad, but definitely wasn't as good as some other restaurants in Milwaukee. Their outdoor seating is quite nice on a warm summer evening and the service was excellent!

View More View Less
0

Contributor

Member since Aug, 2003 View Profile
1k+Reviews
0Photos
Joined 9 years ago
4.5
April 02, 2004

Terrific steak and seafood served by attentive waitstaff at a classy, old-school supper club.. The Scene
Nestled in the shadows of Milwaukee's medical complex, this 1940s-style supper club has carved a niche with its elegance and high quality. Rich woodwork, bright murals and sharply dressed, attentive servers provide a most inviting place to dine. The sound of Sinatra crooning in the background brings back memories of days gone by.

The Food
Steaks and ultra-fresh seafood are the draw. This is premium Midwestern beef, whether it be a massive porterhouse, a steer tenderloin or the famous New York strip au poivre smothered in cognac sauce. Seafood selections such as crispy blue crab cakes and seared ahi tuna are also first-rate, while specials like the boneless roast duckling are superb. Of course, with a name like Eddie Martini's, the cocktails and wine list are top-shelf as well.

View More View Less
0

jlynch617

Member since Mar, 2004 View Profile
1Review
0Photos
Joined 8 years ago
5.0
March 12, 2004

Great. Had dinner and let waitress order for me. Came back with a great meal that was not on the menu, but among the best I have had. People at other tables scrambled to find my dinner on the menu but could not.

View More View Less
0

spencertm

Member since Oct, 2003 View Profile
1Review
0Photos
Joined 9 years ago
5.0
October 25, 2003

Service Excellence. Eddie Martini's sets the bar of service excellence and exceptional dining experience in the Milwaukee area. Many other restaurant owners should experience it and learn from it!

0

nolan

Member since Jul, 2003 View Profile
1Review
0Photos
Joined 9 years ago
4.5
July 09, 2003

Never Better. If ever in the Milwaukee area, this resturant is a must go. However with such a limited seating area reservations a required. The food is absolutly the best I have had. The steaks are only the tip of Iceberg in there case. The seafood is a must try starting with the Ocean Martini!! A collosal martini glass that is filled with seafood from around the world. Last comment, Great Service!

View More View Less
0

Things to do near Eddie Martini's